>>

Monday, November 23, 2009

Borders and Monarchy

As mentioned, Europe shapes up into countries that struggle with each other. The way they form and how they keep power and peace is unique. France inherits the legacy of Charlemagne; England has an important geography (it's an island); Germany bears the brunt of its tribal past; Spain shares the stage with the Islamic world, and Italy houses the pope. There is more. Here are a few more details as they get going.


FRANCE
- Hugh Capet (987-996) begins the Capetian house that rules for 30 years.
- Philip II Augustus (1180-1223) wants to get England out of France and he did.
- Louis IX (St Louis) (1226-1270) wants to rule justly and believes himself responsible to God.
- Philip IV (1285-1314) is called “Fair” but he is actually a man of violence. He expells the Jews from France and takes their goods. He comes into conflict with Pope Boniface VIII after he is told he cannot tax the French clergy.

ENGLAND
- William, Duke of Normandy (1066-1087) becomes king by challenging both the Danes and the Anglo-Saxons.
- Henry II (1154-1189) acquires Scotland and parts of France through marriage. He also accomplishes in centralizing the court system from the feudal system which stimulates a common law.
- Thomas Becket becomes a point of conflict for Henry II. Henry is not able to regulate the church courts and Becket is stubbornly independent. Henry says one night that he wishes to be relieved of the troublesome Becket. Four knights go out and murdered him on the high alter of the cathedral.
- Recall Richard the Lion Hearted, his brother John and the story of Robin Hood (1189-1216)? It is linked to major revisions in England.
- In 1215, the Magna Carta (in part due the current abuses) is signed into law that binds the king to observe all feudal rights and privileges - It says that the law is above the king and the king can be compelled by force to obey the law of the land.

In future no official shall place a man on trial upon his own unsupported statement, without producing credible witnesses to the truth of it... No free man shall be seized or imprisoned, or stripped of his rights or possessions, or outlawed or exiled, or deprived of his standing in any other way, nor will we proceed with force against him, or send others to do so, except by the lawful judgement of his equals or by the law of the land.... To no one will we sell, to no one deny or delay right or justice.
- Parliament or the Great Council brings together representatives from all the shires beginning in 1265 and it's reorganized in 1295 by Edward.
- Edward I becomes the first English king with the goal of taking the whole island of Britain. In 1284, they take Wales and by the time of his death on 1307, they own it all.

GERMANY
- In 936 (to 973) Otto comes to the throne as the Duke of Saxony and founder of the Saxon dynasty of kings. He attempts to control the dukes by appointing other people to offices. He also garners a strong alliance with the Church and used it as leverage against the dukes. He appoints bishops (which is part of lay investitures).
- In 951 Otto invades Italy. He receives the homage of the Italian nobility and assumes the title "King of the Lombards." Among his reasons to step into Italy include the protection of the bishop of Rome (the Pope post 1054).
- In 962, Otto declares himself king of Italy. He is crowned emperor by the pope, making his the first official Holy Roman Empire.
- Henry III, the German king, ruling from what is today northern German and the Holy Roman Emperor, is moved by piety to change the Church. He suppresses the political factions having influence over the papacy and starts appointing a series of popes. One such pope, Leo IX (1049-54), condemns the selling of Church offices and calls for an enforcement of celibacy for clerics.
- Under Henry IV (1056-1106) the dynasty becomes strong but along this time Gregory VII is gaining power for the papacy. Who will control the German churches? That's the big issue.
- Fredrick I of Barbarossa (1150-1190 rule) wants all of Italy, but the Pope has forged an alliance with northern Italy called the Lombard League. Fredrick can't take Italy by force so what did he do? He turns to marriage alliances and his son weds the heiress of Naples and Sicily.
Fredrick II (1212-1250) is Barbarossa’s grandson and he is orphaned and Pope Innocent III (as a ward) raises him. Fredrick is elected emperor by the help from the pope in 1215.
- He transfers crown lands to German princes due to their loyalty in the war in Italy. But by the middle of the 14th Century, Germany had disunited and separated into at least 200 political units.

SPAIN
- This was a different go because of the Muslim influence and the country had to be reconquested. As early as the ninth century there's an effort to do this. This is a gradual process that was ultimately forced in the fifteenth century.


READ MORE

The Medieval Church

There are events that lead up to a discrediting of the Church and the makings of a Europe that divided itself into better defined countries. There are some significant high points in the Medieval Church. St Francis and St Thomas Aquinas are two examples. There are also a series of crusades which have mixed results and become part of the controversy in the Church as to its secular and religious roles.

Here are several things we addressed:

- At Cluny (in 910) the Benedictine order is created to “free the church from secular control and subject it to papal authority." There are many monks trained at Cluny and go out to fuel the growing need of priests.

- In 1054 the Great Schism which serves as the official break between the East and West.

- Pope Gregory VII (1073-1085) prohibits lay investiture which meant that the king could not act as a priest. This essentially gave more control to the Church but this, as we know, will continue to be an issue.

- St Bernard of Clairvaux (1091-1153) pulls the church back to piety and humility, a needed corrective.

- In 1095, Pope Urban II proclaims the First Crusade to establish Christian control of the Holy Land as opposed to Islam or other powers from the East (the Seljuks). Urban II does not proceed to stand at the head of the knights and lead the charge to the Holy Land. Rather, the Church gives the signal that prompts a loose knit of knights to form. This creates problems. Now you have 10,000 men of whom you've blessed both sword and shield.

- The knights led by Count Emicho start forcing conversion of Jews in Speyer and Worms (Germany) and kill those who won't believe. (This was on their way to the Holy Land.) At least 800 Jews were killed in Worms despite the Church's effort to hide Jews from this force that they could not match.

- When they make it to the Holy Land, they easily conquer it.

- There are a number of less effective crusades. The fourth crusade (1202-1204), for example, is a disaster religiously and economically. The Venetian merchants are funding the knights passage but they can't pay them, so the Venetians say they can repay their debts by taking out the town on Zara. They then pressure them to take out Constantinople, which they do.

- Pope Innocent III (1198-1216) starts off a series of popes that are not monks like Gregory VII and others. Innocent is a lawyer trained in the rules of the church. His tenure as pope not only wants to reform the hearts of people but also to systemize and organize the church’s administration. He uses spiritual penalties to isolate people (excommunication) and whole countries (interdict). He uses the strategy of interdiction 85 times.

- Heresy was still a problem. In 1208, Innocent approves attacks on the French region of Toulouse. In 1233, an office of the Inquisition is put in place to weed out heretics. A legal council takes the accused subject to a court where they are to confess and be reconciled after a time of penance. If no confession, they are tortured.

- St Francis of Assisi (1182-1226) begins the Franciscans who reject riches and lived among the poor.

- St Dominic (1170-1221) had fought the heretics in southern France. He starts the Dominicans to be friar-preachers.

- Cathedral schools are instituted to teach more than just future priests. This developed into professional studies of law, medicine and theology.

- St Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274) ushers in a high point of scholarship with his Summa Theologica. In it, he takes up both the truths of faith and the truths of natural reason. Excerpts:

Even if it is given that someone understands the name ‘God’ to signify what is said, namely, ‘that than which a greater cannot be conceived,’ it does not follow that what is signified by this name exists in the nature of things, but only that it exists in the apprehension of the understanding.

Good and evil are essential differences of the act of the will. For good and evil pertain essentially to the will; just as truth and falsehood pertain to the reason, the act of which is distinguished essentially by the difference of truth and falsehood (according as we say that an opinion is true or false.) Consequently, good and evil volition are acts differing in species.

The knowledge of God is the cause of things. For the knowledge of God is to all creatures what the knowledge of the artificer is to things made by his art.

Law is nothing other than a certain ordinance of reason for the common good, promulgated by the person who has the care of the community.


READ MORE