History is the effort to reconstruct the past to discover what people thought, what they did, and how their beliefs and actions continue to influence human life. Now, with that statement comes a set of responsibilities to the study of history and how we interact with it.
Owen Barfield coined the term "chronological snobbery", which he says is the presumption, fueled by the modern conception of progress, that all thinking, all art, and all science of an earlier time are inherently inferior, indeed childlike compared to the present. Under the rule of chronological snobbery, the West has convinced itself that "intellectually, humanity languished for countless generations in the most childish errors on all sorts of crucial subjects, until it was redeemed by some simple scientific dictum of the last century."
As a result, says Barfield, anything more than 100 years is ancient and books are gathering dusty ideas in just 10 years time.
So, what separates us - you and I in our contemporary contexts - and them - the ancients, the dead, the has-beens?
>>
Monday, August 10, 2009
What is History?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
8 comments:
I like the picture...it's a classic. I was thinking during class about a discussion I had in high school about this. We discussed the fact that we cannot judge the decisions people made in the past because we were not there and we can never feel the full affects of all of the things going on at the time. We just have to study the past and learn from the things that went on and if it was bad try not to let it happen again (great depression) and if it was good we should try to recreate it for the times we are in now (New Deal).
In a different vein from what you said, Brittany, I remembered a quote from Aldous Huxley and went to look it up: "the charm of history and its enigmatic lesson consist in the fact that, from age to age, nothing changes and yet everything is completely different." Akin to the message in "One Hundred Years of Solitude", methinks : )
I think that we can make so many assumptions when studying the past because there is a somewhat consistant formula for how we live life and what we require to do so. (like plants and photosynthesis; sunlight, h20..etc.) And I agree that it's all about recreating the conditions present when the New Deals and Salt Marches in history happened..
I agree with you Brittany. It is hard to say what you would do in a certain situation until an unfortunate predicament was thrown upon you. Learning how to create a better society comes from not only the positive actions, but also the negative ones.
I think that it is ridiculous for us as Americans living in the twenty-first century to assume that the advances we have made in every part of our day-to-day lives makes us surperior to those who came before us. Creations and inventions build on each other. Without record players, tape players and CD players may have taken much longer to be invented. We need to recognize that without the initiative our ancestors showed in making a better life for themselves, we would be nowhere near where we are today both technologically and intellectually.
The picture reminds of an ultimate frisbee I once saw, but as for the topic, it kinda reminds of the idea of Manifest Destiny. We (as Americans) thought we had the "God" given right to go explore the West, and that it was "ours" for the taking. I'm not saying I'm agreeing with this idea, but that is what I think it resembles
I agree with Brittany.History is the biggest learning tool available to all of us.History teaches us the right and wrong ways of doing something.It also gives us a sense of purpose on how we live our everyday lives.History,the present and the past have all one thing in common and that is time.once time has gone everything will be history.
History is important. It can teach us what to not do in the future. however, i feel that if you think too much about the past, you will miss out on what is going on currently in the world.
i like what michael said. yes we can learn from the past, but we are in the present. and it is VERY different now than it was then. so can learning about past civilizations really help us now? i'm not too sure, so i'm going to go study more history to decide ;D
Post a Comment