
We read some of Hammurabi's law code in class. The most famous one says that if you take my eye, your eye will also be taken. This seems like brutal justice. Yes? What are your thoughts about Hammurabi and some of the reasons he may have introduced these kinds of codes in a permanent way?
>>
Tuesday, August 25, 2009
You Take My Eye, I Take Yours
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
9 comments:
In on aspect i feel like Hamurrabis Code is taking it to far by being so brutal. But on the other hand i feel that it makes people want to do right all the time. It gives people the drive to do things perfectly instead of just giving a sloppy effort. I would also assume that there was not much crime committed because of the brutal outcome if they were caught.
It seems strange that we find Hamurrabi's "eye for an eye" idea brutal, when that very adage is used today to justify capital punishment in our society.
Though we use this punishment in more extreme cases, and distribute punishments more equally than back then (Or do we? What about OJ...) this idea of revenge for the wronged an punishment for the wrong - doer seems to have been a very permanent idea throughout the years.
"an eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind" (Gandhiji) Was society more brutal then than now or do we just have more surviving literature today that protests against such laws? (showing that there is not consensus on the brutality of laws still in effect. Good point about capital punishment, Taylor) Were there peacemakers in 1790 bce? This brooches on the topic of what is the role of government to its people)
And the question that still prevails today is: what can we do to create a society based on compassion rather than hatred and extermination?
I believe that Hammurabi felt the need to implement these laws or rules to make sure people respected him. If a leader is too lenient, his citizens will know that they are able to walk all over him, and even slide around some rules and regulations. "An eye for an eye" seems harsh, but like Taylor said, if you murder someone, your punishment is death. What's the difference? We may think that it's more brutal because it seems archaic, but I think that the two punishments are equal and just.
I mostly agree with what everyone is saying...Hammurrabi's Laws like someone said in class was most likely the "norm" for what the rules and morals for the time. And like Haley said he need to be respected also so some of them may seem alittle harsh but you have to keep people in line so that they don't get out of control.
I feel like this punishment they practiced at this time seemed normal and needed for their era, but of course now most people feel this is too harsh and something we do not need to practice anymore. It just goes with the time era's you live in to decipher what kind of punishment is respected.
I respect your opinions, Brittany and Mary, but I do not agree that "you have to keep people in line so that they don't get out of control" and that respect comes from fear(punishment). If we are to relate Hammurabi's form of government to our current one, I do not think that so little has changed in the almost 4 millennia since his time. It is my opinion that, and I don't mean to sound lofty, fear is the destruction of respect, for one does not respect themselves in this state of fear, nor the person dolling out a punishment that creates this fear. I recognize that there cannot be a universal government which answers everyone's wishes, but I will say that a government that asks only for obedience and fails to give respect in return is asking for a mobocracy or else a non-lasting organization.
I do not believe Hammurabbi was trying to be brutal.I believe he set these laws because he thought poeple would not break them because of the consequences.I believe he thought he might have to make examples out of people but eventually he would never have to act on these laws.Some of his laws do seem a little contraversial but some i do completley agree with. I do believe in "a eye for a eye".
Hamurrabi is a bit brutal, but I can see that this was a somewhat verson of the golden rule. And eye for an eye is kind of like treat others how you would like to be treated. It was brutal, but people obeyed him because of it. It wasn't a bad system.
Post a Comment